That atmosphere of Tiny Tiki is "surfy and tropical," featuring surf music, faux tropical plants, tiki masks, colored glass floats and rattan furnishings in the cozy, max 30 capacity space — hence its name. When Ingersoll finally reopened the Tiny Tiki in February of 2024, he was careful not to change much. The House Piña is one of the most popular drinks, as well as Tiny Tiki's twist on the drink, a Peanut Colada, made with rum, peanut butter whiskey, coconut and pineapple.